Price-performance benchmark Apache Druid and Google BigQuery
Jun 25, 2020
Rick Bilodeau
Summary
To fully capitalize on the troves of data made available through digital transformation efforts, businesses need to provide self-service analytics to hundreds or thousands of front-line decision makers. Understandably, many would like to use their cloud data warehouse for this type of use case, which we call “hot analytics“. While data warehouses are excellent at many things, they are not architected for hot analytics use cases, which are characterized by iterative, ad hoc queries against large data sets at high query concurrency.
Imply was purpose-built for this type of workload. To assess its performance, we recently benchmarked the performance and cost of Google BigQuery, a popular cloud data warehouse, against that of Apache Druid, the real-time analytics database at the core of Imply.
The test indicates that Apache Druid delivers 3 times the speed and 12 times the price-performance of Google BigQuery. Druid responds to queries 3.1 times faster than BigQuery on average and performs faster for every query tested; up to 14.3 times faster. If you normalize the cluster size to provide the same performance, Druid costs 8% as much as BigQuery. This leads to substantial dollar savings. For 128 concurrent queries running continually, the monthly estimated costs are $212,500 for BigQuery compared to $17,900 for Druid.
The test used the star schema benchmark (SSB) and a 100GB data set. We believe that this advantage would grow using Imply Pivot as the visual UI for Druid vs. a popular BI interface such as Looker or Tableau as the front-end for BigQuery. Pivot was purpose-built for ad hoc queries; the others are designed to deliver recurring queries that populate dashboards and static reports.
The results can be explained by comparing the architectures of the two systems. BigQuery separates storage and compute to allow for instant elasticity; Druid combines them to improve speed. BigQuery has no secondary indexes or data tiering so as to simplify management, Druid provides both, allowing the customer to optimize performance.
Based on these results, customers should consider offloading self-service analytics use cases from BigQuery to a Druid-based system such as Imply, which uses Druid as a processing engine to deliver a real-time data platform for self-service analytics.
We expect Druid’s performance advantage would hold against other cloud data warehouses, such as AWS Redshift, Azure Synapse Analytics or Snowflake, as they are all similarly architected and have shown similar performance to one another in previous benchmarks.
Rationale and test method
Cloud data warehouses have become a popular replacement for enterprise data warehouses due to their management simplicity, elasticity, and cost advantages. Examples include offerings from the top 3 cloud platforms – AWS Redshift, Azure Synapse Analytics, Google BigQuery – plus Snowflake Data Warehouse. Google BigQuery has received a lot of market attention lately, so we thought it would be informative to see how its performance and cost compares to Apache Druid.
For the test we used the Star Schema Benchmark (SSB), which is a dataset and query set designed to evaluate performance of data warehouses over the past decade. The performance results of 13 standard SQL queries allows for comparison across products and configurations.
For this benchmark, 600 million rows (approximately 100GB) of test data were generated, using SSB’s dbgen, and executed locally. Dbgen was executed with a Scale Factor of 1 (SF=1) to generate a lineorder table with 6,000,000 rows.
Each of the 13 queries were run 10 times in each test flight, and there were 5 flight runs. Results were averaged per flight run, then per standard benchmark practices, the fastest and slowest results were considered outliers and discarded before analyzing the results. The remaining results were averaged to provide a final result.
To compare infrastructure costs, Druid was run using Imply Cloud with JMeter servers running on AWS instances, while BigQuery was tested with JMeter running on Google Cloud Platform.
Findings
Performance
The overall SSB test results for Druid and BigQuery, shown below, indicate that Druid performed faster on all 13 queries. The performance advantage ranged from 1.1x faster for query 1.1 to 14.3x faster for query 1.3. For the aggregate flight time on average, Druid was 3.1x faster; Druid took 6.0 seconds to run the query set while BigQuery took 19.4 seconds. Druid averaged 0.5 seconds per query and BigQuery averaged 1.5 seconds.
Query response is not the same as user response. A single request from a user, such as loading a dashboard or initiating a drag-and-drop operation in a visual UI, often requires several SQL queries to execute. Thus, an average query response of a second can easily grow to a 5-10 second wait time for the user, and a 2 second average query response might become unusable for interactive analytics.
Also, this benchmark was conducted on a relatively small data set (100MB) executed by a single user. Increases in data set size and query concurrency negatively impact query speed, given the same computing resources.
Lastly, there is reason to believe that BigQuery was at its performance floor in this benchmark, whereas Druid still had room to further reduce response times. For the test run, BigQuery, which dynamically allocates resources, chose to allocate far less than the full allotment of slots available. This may indicate that applying additional capacity was not expected to improve performance. Druid normally hits a performance floor at about 5 million rows per core, and in this test ran at about 50 million rows per core, meaning the core count could have increased 10x and still delivered performance gains.
Price-performance
Costs for Druid on AWS and Big Query were compared. Two price plans are offered for Google BigQuery: an on-demand price plan based on data scanned, and a flat rate fixed-slot price plan where a customer reserves the right to use a maximum amount of compute capacity. For Druid, the infrastructure costs are the costs of the AWS instances required to run the cluster.
To compare pricing we normalized the Druid cluster to a size where it would run the query flight at the same speed as BigQuery and then compared those infrastructure costs to the slot costs of BigQuery. In both cases we took advantage of the longest available contractual commit to obtain the lowest cost.
Druid exhibited a minimum 12x price-performance advantage over BigQuery based on the flat-rate fixed-slot plan that most large enterprises would choose.
In terms of dollars spent, there is an order-of-magnitude difference between Druid and BigQuery. This advantage grows from roughly $8,000 a month at lower concurrency to $195,000 a month for capacity to execute 128 simultaneous queries ($212,500 vs. $17,900).
We also looked at price-performance using the BigQuery On-Demand pricing structure which charges $5 per TB scanned. This price plan is only economical for BigQuery users at relatively low queries volumes (under 10,000 queries per month). Above this level the BigQuery Flat Rate price plan becomes dominant.
As the chart shows, the Druid holds the advantage at 1,000 queries per month and this advantage grows quickly with scale. This is not surprising given that a single Druid server was shown to scale up to roughly 400,000 SSB queries per month.
Explaining what we found
There are some key differences between Druid and BigQuery that drive Druid’s advantage as shown in this benchmark.
Remote vs. local storage: cloud data warehouses like Snowflake & BigQuery need to retrieve data from remote storage during query execution, which slows them down. Druid prefetches data before it is queried, eliminating this source of slowdown.
Secondary indexes: cloud data warehouses do not index the data beyond the partition key. Instead, they rely on adding compute capacity to scale performance through brute-force. Of course, the customer has to reserve and pay for this capacity. Druid maintains space-efficient secondary indexes to minimize needless data scanning and processing.
Data tiering: cloud data warehouses give you “one size fits all” when it comes to performance and cost. Druid lets you control which data gets “hot” vs. “warm” vs. “cold” performance.
Implications for the enterprise
The move to cloud data warehouses has been driven by a desire to take advantage of the benefits of cloud computing and offload or eliminate expensive and difficult-to-maintain legacy data warehouses. This primary “EDW replacement” goal is why cloud data warehouses are optimized for complex analytics run by a relatively small number of individuals, namely trained analysts and data scientists.
A new world of self-service analytics is arising as companies harness the data unlocked by their digital transformation efforts over the past decade. This requires making new big data and streaming data sets available for exploration by hundreds or thousands of front-line business people in marketing, product, operations, sales, finance and other functions. Since data exploration is driven by interactive and iterative ad hoc queries, it requires extremely fast response under conditions of high query concurrency.
Use cases that involve broad self-service analytics exist across all organizations and industries. They include analytics for:
Marketing / advertising campaigns and audience segmentation
Digital product, service, website and app user behavior
Network and service performance
Supply chain operations
Fraud, compliance and risk
Given the price-performance advantage Druid demonstrated in this benchmark, it would be wise to evaluate Druid to address these high concurrency, real-time self-service analytics needs.
Resources
If you need more details or need to run your own benchmarks you can find more details in the full benchmark report.
If you want to get started with Druid, Imply features the market’s most advanced Druid distribution and Druid-based cloud service. You can:
If you have any questions or need more information please contact us anytime.
About Imply
Imply transforms how businesses run by integrating real-time analytics into their operations. Founded by the authors of the Apache Druid database, Imply provides a cloud-native real-time data platform that delivers real-time ingestion, interactive ad-hoc queries, and intuitive visualizations for many types of event-driven and streaming data flows. Imply Cloud has operations in North America, Europe, and Asia Pacific and is backed by Andreesen Horowitz, Khosla Ventures, and Geodesic Capital. For more information, please visit imply.io.
Other blogs you might find interesting
No records found...
Sep 27, 2023
Introducing incremental encoding for Apache Druid dictionary encoded columns
In this blog post we deep dive on a recent engineering effort: incremental encoding of STRING columns. In preliminary testing, it has shown to be quite promising at significantly reducing the size of segment...
Migrate Analytics Data from MongoDB to Apache Druid
This blog presents a concise guide on migrating data from MongoDB to Druid. It includes Python scripts to extract data from MongoDB, save it as CSV, and then ingest it into Druid. It also touches on maintaining...
How Druid Facilitates Real-Time Analytics for Mass Transit
Mass transit plays a key role in reimagining life in a warmer, more densely populated world. Learn how Apache Druid helps power data and analytics for mass transit.
Migrate Analytics Data from Snowflake to Apache Druid
This blog outlines the steps needed to migrate data from Snowflake to Apache Druid, a platform designed for high-performance analytical queries. The article covers the migration process, including Python scripts...
Apache Kafka, Flink, and Druid: Open Source Essentials for Real-Time Applications
Apache Kafka, Flink, and Druid, when used together, create a real-time data architecture that eliminates all these wait states. In this blog post, we’ll explore how the combination of these tools enables...
Visualizing Data in Apache Druid with the Plotly Python Library
In today's data-driven world, making sense of vast datasets can be a daunting task. Visualizing this data can transform complicated patterns into actionable insights. This blog delves into the utilization of...
Bringing Real-Time Data to Solar Power with Apache Druid
In a rapidly warming world, solar power is critical for decarbonization. Learn how Apache Druid empowers a solar equipment manufacturer to provide real-time data to users, from utility plant operators to homeowners
When to Build (Versus Buy) an Observability Application
Observability is the key to software reliability. Here’s how to decide whether to build or buy your own solution—and why Apache Druid is a popular database for real-time observability
How Innowatts Simplifies Utility Management with Apache Druid
Data is a key driver of progress and innovation in all aspects of our society and economy. By bringing digital data to physical hardware, the Internet of Things (IoT) bridges the gap between the online and...
Three Ways to Use Apache Druid for Machine Learning Workflows
An excellent addition to any machine learning environment, Apache Druid® can facilitate analytics, streamline monitoring, and add real-time data to operations and training
Apache Druid® is an open-source distributed database designed for real-time analytics at scale. Apache Druid 27.0 contains over 350 commits & 46 contributors. This release's focus is on stability and scaling...
Unleashing Real-Time Analytics in APJ: Introducing Imply Polaris on AWS AP-South-1
Imply, the company founded by the original creators of Apache Druid, has exciting news for developers in India seeking to build real-time analytics applications. Introducing Imply Polaris, a powerful database-as-a-Service...
In this guide, we will walk you through creating a very simple web app that shows a different embedded chart for each user selected from a drop-down. While this example is simple it highlights the possibilities...
Automate Streaming Data Ingestion with Kafka and Druid
In this blog post, we explore the integration of Kafka and Druid for data stream management and analysis, emphasizing automatic topic detection and ingestion. We delve into the creation of 'Ingestion Spec',...
This guide explores configuring Apache Druid to receive Kafka streaming messages. To demonstrate Druid's game-changing automatic schema discovery. Using a real-world scenario where data changes are handled...
Imply Polaris, our ever-evolving Database-as-a-Service, recently focused on global expansion, enhanced security, and improved data handling and visualization. This fully managed cloud service, based on Apache...
Introducing hands-on developer tutorials for Apache Druid
The objective of this blog is to introduce the new set of interactive tutorials focused on the Druid API fundamentals. These tutorials are available as Jupyter Notebooks and can be downloaded as a Docker container.
In this blog article I’ll unpack schema auto-discovery, a new feature now available in Druid 26.0, that enables Druid to automatically discover data fields and data types and update tables to match changing...
Druid now has a new function, Unnest. Unnest explodes an array into individual elements. This blog contains design methodology and examples for this new Unnest function both from native and SQL binding perspectives.
What’s new in Imply Polaris – Our Real-Time Analytics DBaaS
Every week we add new features and capabilities to Imply Polaris. This month, we’ve expanded security capabilities, added new query functionality, and made it easier to monitor your service with your preferred...
Apache Druid® 26.0, an open-source distributed database for real-time analytics, has seen significant improvements with 411 new commits, a 40% increase from version 25.0. The expanded contributor base of 60...
How to Build a Sentiment Analysis Application with ChatGPT and Druid
Leveraging ChatGPT for sentiment analysis, when combined with Apache Druid, offers results from large data volumes. This integration is easily achievable, revealing valuable insights and trends for businesses...
In this blog, we will compare Snowflake and Druid. It is important to note that reporting data warehouses and real-time analytics databases are different domains. Choosing the right tool for your specific requirements...
Learn how to achieve sub-second responses with Apache Druid
Learn how to achieve sub-second responses with Apache Druid. This article is an in-depth look at how Druid resolves queries and describes data modeling techniques that improve performance.
Apache Druid uses load rules to manage the ageing of segments from one historical tier to another and finally to purge old segments from the cluster. In this article, we’ll show what happens when you make...
Real-Time Analytics: Building Blocks and Architecture
This blog identifies the key technical considerations for real-time analytics. It answers what is the right data architecture and why. It spotlights the technologies used at Confluent, Reddit, Target and 1000s...
What’s new in Imply Polaris – Our Real-Time Analytics DBaaS
This blog explains some of the new features, functionality and connectivity added to Imply Polaris over the last two months. We've expanded ingestion capabilities, simplified operations and increased reliability...
Wow, that was easy – Up and running with Apache Druid
The objective of this blog is to provide a step-by-step guide on setting up Druid locally, including the use of SQL ingestion for importing data and executing analytical queries.
Tales at Scale Podcast Kicks off with the Apache Druid Origin Story
Tales at Scale cracks open the world of analytics projects and shares stories from developers and engineers who are building analytics applications or working within the real-time data space. One of the key...
Real-time Analytics Database uses partitioning and pruning to achieve its legendary performance
Apache Druid uses partitioning (splitting data) and pruning (selecting subset of data) to achieve its legendary performance. Learn how to use the CLUSTERED BY clause during ingestion for performance and high...
Easily embed analytics into your own apps with Imply’s DBaaS
This blog explains how developers can leverage Imply Polaris to embed robust visualization options directly into their own applications without them having to build a UI. This is super important because consuming...
Building an Event Analytics Pipeline with Confluent Cloud and Imply’s real time DBaaS, Polaris
Learn how to set up a pipeline that generates a simulated clickstream event stream and sends it to Confluent Cloud, processes the raw clickstream data using managed ksqlDB in Confluent Cloud, delivers the processed...
We are excited to announce the availability of Imply Polaris in Europe, specifically in AWS eu-central-1 region based in Frankfurt. Since its launch in March 2022, Imply Polaris, the fully managed Database-as-a-Service...
Should You Build or Buy Security Analytics for SecOps?
When should you build—or buy—a security analytics platform for your environment? Here are some common considerations—and how Apache Druid is the ideal foundation for any in-house security solution.
Combating financial fraud and money laundering at scale with Apache Druid
Learn how Apache Druid enables financial services firms and FinTech companies to get immediate insights from petabytes-plus data volumes for anti-fraud and anti-money laundering compliance.
This is a what's new to Imply in Dec 2022. We’ve added two new features to Imply Polaris to make it easier for your end users to take advantage of real-time insights.
Imply Pivot delivers the final mile for modern analytics applications
This blog is focused on how Imply Pivot delivers the final mile for building an anlaytics app. It showcases two customer examples - Twitch and ironsource.
For decades, analytics has been defined by the standard reporting and BI workflow, supported by the data warehouse. Now, 1000s of companies are realizing an expansion of analytics beyond reporting, which requires...
Apache Druid is at the heart of Imply. We’re an open source business, and that’s why we’re committed to making Druid the best open source database for modern analytics applications
When it comes to modern data analytics applications, speed is of the utmost importance. In this blog we discuss two approximation algorithms which can be used to greatly enhance speed with only a slight reduction...
The next chapter for Imply Polaris: celebrating 250+ accounts, continued innovation
Today we announced the next iteration of Imply Polaris, the fully managed Database-as-a-Service that helps you build modern analytics applications faster, cheaper, and with less effort. Since its launch in...
We obviously talk a lot about #ApacheDruid on here. But what are folks actually building with Druid? What is a modern analytics application, exactly? Let's find out
Elasticity is important, but beware the database that can only save you money when your application is not in use. The best solution will have excellent price-performance under all conditions.
Druid 0.23 – Features And Capabilities For Advanced Scenarios
Many of Druid’s improvements focus on building a solid foundation, including making the system more stable, easier to use, faster to scale, and better integrated with the rest of the data ecosystem. But for...
Apache Druid 0.23.0 contains over 450 updates, including new features, major performance enhancements, bug fixes, and major documentation improvements.
Imply Polaris is a fully managed database-as-a-service for building realtime analytics applications. John is the tech lead for the Polaris UI, known internally as the Unified App. It began with a profound question:...
There is a new category within data analytics emerging which is not centered in the world of reports and dashboards (the purview of data analysts and data scientists), but instead centered in the world of applications...
We are in the early stages of a stream revolution, as developers build modern transactional and analytic applications that use real-time data continuously delivered.
Developers and architects must look beyond query performance to understand the operational realities of growing and managing a high performance database and if it will consume their valuable time.
Building high performance logging analytics with Polaris and Logstash
When you think of querying with Apache Druid, you probably imagine queries over massive data sets that run in less than a second. This blog is about some of the things we did as a team to discover the user...
Horizontal scaling is the key to performance at scale, which is why every database claims this. You should investigate, though, to see how much effort it takes, especially compared to Apache Druid.
When you think of querying with Apache Druid, you probably imagine queries over massive data sets that run in less than a second. This blog is about some of the things we did as a team to discover the user...
Building Analytics for External Users is a Whole Different Animal
Analytics aren’t just for internal stakeholders anymore. If you’re building an analytics application for customers, then you’re probably wondering…what’s the right database backend?
After over 30 years of working with data analytics, we’ve been witness (and sometimes participant) to three major shifts in how we find insights from data - and now we’re looking at the fourth.
Every year industry pundits predict data and analytics becoming more valuable the following year. But this doesn’t take a crystal ball to predict. There’s instead something much more interesting happening...
Today, I'm prepared to share our progress on this effort and some of our plans for the future. But before diving further into that, let's take a closer look at how Druid's core query engine executes queries,...
Product Update: SSO, Cluster level authorization, OAuth 2.0 and more security features
When you think of querying with Apache Druid, you probably imagine queries over massive data sets that run in less than a second. This blog is about some of the things we did as a team to discover the user...
When you think of querying with Apache Druid, you probably imagine queries over massive data sets that run in less than a second. This blog is about some of the things we did as a team to discover the user...
Druid Nails Cost Efficiency Challenge Against ClickHouse & Rockset
To make a long story short, we were pleased to confirm that Druid is 2 times faster than ClickHouse and 8 times faster than Rockset with fewer hardware resources!.
Unveiling Project Shapeshift Nov. 9th at Druid Summit 2021
There is a new category within data analytics emerging which is not centered in the world of reports and dashboards (the purview of data analysts and data scientists), but instead centered in the world of applications...
How we made long-running queries work in Apache Druid
When you think of querying with Apache Druid, you probably imagine queries over massive data sets that run in less than a second. This blog is about some of the things we did as a team to discover the user...
Uneven traffic flow in streaming pipelines is a common problem. Providing the right level of resources to keep up with spikes in demand is a requirement in order to deliver timely analytics.
Community Discoveries: multi-value dimensions in Apache Druid
Hellmar Becker is an Imply solutions engineer based in Germany, where he has been delving into the nooks-and-crannies of multi-valued dimension support in Druid. In this interview, Hellmar explains why...
Community Spotlight: Apache Pulsar and Apache Druid get close…
The community team at Imply spoke with an Apache Pulsar community member, Giannis Polyzos, about how collaboration between open source communities generates great things, and more specifically, about how...